ProductSearch: Ben & Jerry's Reviews of 2026

15 products Updated August 3, 2026

Ben & Jerry's Products (15)

Ben & Jerry's Milk & Cookies Ice Cream: Vanilla Pint with Chocolate Cookie Swirl, Chip & Double Chocolate Cookies - 16oz

Ben & Jerry's

9.9

View on Amazon Best Buy Walmart

Pros & Cons

Pros

Insanely delicious cookie variety in every bite
High 4.8/5 rating reflects superior taste
Ethical sourcing boosts quality and feel-good factor
Generous 16 oz pint size for sharing or savoring

Cons

High indulgence may overwhelm lighter dessert seekers
Premium pricing at $4.99 reflects quality ingredients
Dairy-based, not suitable for vegans

Ben & Jerry's Chocolate Fudge Brownie Ice Cream Pint 16 oz - Rich Dark Chocolate with Fudgy Brownie Chunks, Non-GMO & Fairtrade

Ben & Jerry's

9.8

View on Amazon Best Buy Walmart

Pros & Cons

Pros

Rich, creamy chocolate base with substantial brownie pieces
Ethically sourced ingredients including Fairtrade and non-GMO
Exceptional taste proven by 4.7/5 rating from 5,855 reviews
Supports social good through Greyston Bakery partnership
Kosher and made with humane cage-free eggs

Cons

High in calories and sugar, best for occasional treats
Premium pricing reflects quality ingredients
Melts quickly like all premium ice creams if not stored properly

Ben & Jerry's Half Baked Ice Cream Pint: Chocolate & Vanilla with Cookie Dough & Fudge Brownies, 16 oz

Ben & Jerry's

9.8

View on Amazon Best Buy Walmart

Pros & Cons

Pros

Explosive flavor from two legendary mix-ins: cookie dough and brownies
Ethically sourced Fairtrade and non-GMO ingredients
Outstanding 4.7/5 rating from over 4,700 reviews
Generous portions of chunks in a 16 oz pint
Kosher certified dairy for broad appeal

Cons

High in sugar and calories due to rich mix-ins
Contains dairy, not suitable for vegans or lactose-intolerant
Melts quickly if not eaten promptly

Ben & Jerry's Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream Pint 16oz - Creamy Vanilla with Real Cookie Dough Chunks, Fairtrade & Non-GMO

Ben & Jerry's

9.8

View on Amazon Best Buy Walmart

Pros & Cons

Pros

Huge, delicious cookie dough chunks in every bite
Exceptional 4.7/5 stars from over 4600 reviews
Ethically sourced with Fairtrade and non-GMO ingredients
Creamy texture holds up with perfect dough consistency
Kosher certified for broader appeal

Cons

High in calories as a rich indulgence treat
Dairy-based, not suitable for vegans
Premium price reflects quality ingredients

Ben & Jerry's Vanilla Ice Cream Pint 16oz - Rich Creamy Fairtrade Non-GMO Kosher Dairy

Ben & Jerry's

9.8

View on Amazon Best Buy Walmart

Pros & Cons

Pros

Exceptionally flavorful vanilla exceeding expectations
Ethical Fairtrade and Non-GMO sourcing
High 4.7/5 rating from 2778+ reviews
Cage-free eggs and humane standards
Responsibly sourced packaging

Cons

Premium price reflects quality ingredients
Pure vanilla may feel plain without mix-ins
Melts like all premium ice creams if not stored properly

Ben & Jerry's Chunky Monkey Ice Cream: Banana Pint with Fudge Chunks & Walnuts, 16 oz - Fairtrade, Non-GMO

Ben & Jerry's

9.8

View on Amazon Best Buy Walmart

Pros & Cons

Pros

Generous fudge chunks and walnuts provide exciting texture contrast
Impossibly smooth banana ice cream base from Fairtrade sources
Non-GMO, cage-free eggs, and ethical ingredients appeal to conscious consumers
Iconic, time-tested flavor with widespread appeal
Kosher certified for broader dietary compatibility

Cons

Contains walnuts and potential allergens like dairy and soy
High in sugar and calories as a rich indulgence
Melts quickly like all premium ice creams if not stored properly

Ben & Jerry's The Tonight Dough Ice Cream Pint 16 oz - Caramel Chocolate with Cookie Dough Swirls & Chunks, Jimmy Fallon Inspired

Ben & Jerry's

9.8

View on Amazon Best Buy Walmart

Pros & Cons

Pros

Incredibly chunky and dough-filled for maximum texture and flavor
Supports children's charity with every purchase
Ethical ingredients: Fairtrade, Non-GMO, cage-free eggs
High 4.7 rating reflects broad appeal
Made with caring dairy from family farms

Cons

Extremely rich and indulgent, may overwhelm lighter dessert preferences
Dairy-based, not suitable for vegans or lactose-intolerant
Premium pricing typical of Ben & Jerry's specialty pints

Ben & Jerry's Americone Dream Ice Cream: Vanilla with Fudge Waffle Cone Pieces & Caramel Swirl - 16oz Pint

Ben & Jerry's

9.8

View on Amazon Best Buy Walmart

Pros & Cons

Pros

Unique, addictive flavor combo praised by fans and Colbert
Ethical sourcing boosts feel-good factor with every bite
Premium ingredients ensure superior creaminess and taste
Generous 16oz pint size for sharing or savoring
Charitable impact aids important causes

Cons

High in calories and sugar, not ideal for strict diets
Dairy-based, unsuitable for vegans or lactose-intolerant
Premium pricing compared to basic ice creams

Ben & Jerry's Non-Dairy Chocolate Fudge Brownie Vegan Ice Cream Pint, Oat Milk, 16oz - Fairtrade Certified

Ben & Jerry's

9.8

View on Amazon Best Buy Walmart

Pros & Cons

Pros

Exceptional creamy texture from oat milk base, praised by chocolate ice cream fans
High 4.6/5 rating from 3455 reviews confirms top-tier taste
Supports social good via Greyston Bakery brownies
Fairtrade and non-GMO ingredients boost quality and ethics
Certified vegan appeals to plant-based diets

Cons

Premium pricing compared to traditional dairy ice cream
Oat milk base may not suit those with oat sensitivities
Limited availability in some stores as a specialty non-dairy item

Ben & Jerry's Vanilla Caramel Fudge Ice Cream Pint - Creamy Vanilla with Gooey Caramel & Fudge Swirls, 473ml Non-GMO

Ben & Jerry's

9.8

View on Amazon Best Buy Walmart

Pros & Cons

Pros

Exceptional 4.6/5 rating from 2,537 reviews highlights consistent creaminess
Rich, balanced flavors of vanilla, caramel, and fudge please chunk-averse fans
Responsibly sourced ingredients like Fairtrade and Non-GMO build trust
Smooth texture stands out as a classic, reliable choice

Cons

Premium pricing at $4.48 may feel steep for everyday treats
Dairy-heavy; not suitable for lactose-intolerant or vegan diets
Swirls can separate if not eaten quickly after scooping

Ben & Jerry's Non-Dairy Cherry Garcia Vegan Ice Cream Pint - Cherries & Fudge Flakes, Oat Milk, 16 oz

Ben & Jerry's

9.8

View on Amazon Best Buy Walmart

Pros & Cons

Pros

Tastes remarkably close to original dairy version
Loaded with real cherries and dark chocolate chunks
High praise for freshness and packaging in reviews
Versatile for dairy-free diets with no compromise on euphoria

Cons

Initial bites may taste light before hitting cherries or chocolate
Some compare it unfavorably to premium vegan alternatives like Van Leeuwen

Detailed Review

Ben & Jerry's Non-Dairy Cherry Garcia is a plant-based frozen dessert pint designed for vegans, lactose-intolerant individuals, and fans of the classic Cherry Garcia flavor who want a dairy-free alternative. This 16 oz tub features a smooth oat milk base packed with whole cherries and fudge flakes, capturing the euphoric taste that made the original iconic since 1987.

Standout performance comes from its creamy texture that rivals dairy ice cream, with reviewers noting they 'can't tell it's dairy-free.' The flavor evolves beautifully, starting mild and airy but exploding with cherry sweetness and rich dark chocolate upon hitting the mix-ins. Ethical bonuses include Fairtrade-certified cocoa and vanilla, non-GMO ingredients, and responsibly sourced packaging.

Build quality shines in its compact pint design, perfect for freezers, and arrives well-packed to maintain freshness. While some find the first bites underwhelming compared to ultra-premium vegan options, the overall consensus highlights its addictive quality and value for everyday treats.

Minor drawbacks include a potentially lighter initial profile, but these fade quickly. Verdict: A top choice for non-dairy Cherry Garcia lovers seeking guilt-free joy with social impact.

Specifications

Product Dimensions: 3.88 x 3.88 x 4.11 inches; 14.5 ounces

UPC: 076840674442

Manufacturer: Unilever

ASIN: B06XD55CJH

Units: 16.0 Ounce

Best Sellers Rank: #15,511 in Grocery & Gourmet Food; #3 in Plant-Based Ice Cream & Novelties

Customer Highlights

Reviewers love the dark chocolate quality and generous cherries, with many saying it surpasses expectations for non-dairy. 'Chocolate chunks and cherries... what’s NOT to like??' and 'Can’t tell it’s dairy free' are common praises. Even dairy fans plan to repurchase.

Ben & Jerry's Non-Dairy Phish Food Vegan Ice Cream Pint - Chocolate Fudge Fish, Marshmallow & Caramel Swirls, 16oz

Ben & Jerry's

9.8

View on Amazon Best Buy Walmart

Pros & Cons

Pros

Tastes remarkably close to the dairy original per multiple reviewers
Creamy, airy texture from oat milk base
Ethical Fairtrade and non-GMO sourcing
Supports charity through WaterWheel Foundation
Highly satisfying for vegans and dairy-free diets

Cons

Extremely rich and sweet, best in moderation
May be too intense for regular large servings

Detailed Review

Ben & Jerry's Non-Dairy Phish Food is a 16-ounce pint of certified vegan chocolate frozen dessert designed for those seeking a plant-based alternative to the iconic original. Made with oat milk instead of dairy, it features gooey marshmallow swirls, caramel swirls, and fudge-covered fish-shaped pieces, capturing the rockstar vibe of Phish Food without any animal products. It's perfect for vegans, lactose-intolerant individuals, and anyone craving indulgent ice cream that aligns with ethical eating.

In real-world use, reviewers rave about its spot-on recreation of the classic flavor profile, with a creamy, airy texture that surprises even longtime fans of the dairy version. The chocolate base shines alongside the swirls and fudge fish, delivering never-ending scoops of excitement. Performance holds up well, maintaining smoothness straight from the freezer, and it supports the WaterWheel Foundation just like the original.

Build quality reflects Ben & Jerry's commitment to responsibility, using Fairtrade-certified cocoa, sugar, and vanilla, plus non-GMO ingredients in responsibly sourced packaging. The pint's compact dimensions make it easy to store, and the model upholds the brand's high standards from its Vermont roots.

One minor drawback is its intense richness and sweetness, which some find overwhelming if eaten in large amounts, suggesting smaller portions for balance. Overall, it excels as a top-tier non-dairy option.

Verdict: A must-try encore for Phish Food lovers going dairy-free. Highly recommended for its authentic taste, ethical credentials, and crowd-pleasing appeal.

Specifications

Dimensions: 3.88 x 3.88 x 4.11 inches; 15.08 ounces

Units: 16 Fluid Ounces

Item Model Number: 0076840002917

UPC: 076840002917

Manufacturer: Unilever

ASIN: B08RCZZ7Y4

Best Sellers Rank: #19,378 in Grocery & Gourmet Food; #4 in Plant-Based Ice Cream & Novelties

Ben & Jerry's Milk & Cookies Non-Dairy Vegan Ice Cream Pint - Vanilla with Chocolate Cookies & Swirls, 16oz

Ben & Jerry's

9.7

View on Amazon Best Buy Walmart

Pros & Cons

Pros

Exceptionally creamy non-dairy texture that mimics real ice cream
Abundant, crunchy cookie chunks and swirls for consistent flavor in every scoop
Highly praised by vegans and dairy-free eaters for authentic taste
Versatile treat suitable for allergies, intolerances, and cookie lovers

Cons

Some detect a slight aftertaste after initial creamy flavor
Includes canola oil, which turns off certain health-conscious buyers
Texture and taste may vary slightly from traditional dairy versions

Detailed Review

Ben & Jerry's Milk & Cookies Non-Dairy frozen dessert is a 16oz pint of certified vegan vanilla ice cream crafted for cookie lovers who avoid dairy. Made with an oat milk base, it delivers the creamy consistency fans expect from the brand, packed with chocolate chip cookies, chocolate sandwich cookies, and rich chocolate cookie swirls. This treat targets vegans, lactose-intolerant individuals, and anyone craving indulgent plant-based desserts without compromise.

In real-world testing reflected by customer feedback, the standout performance comes from its spot-on cookie nirvana vibe. Reviewers rave about the Oreo milkshake-like flavor, delish texture, and crunchy cookie pieces that avoid sogginess or uneven distribution. The neutral oat milk foundation lets bold cookie elements shine, making it a top pick among vegan Ben & Jerry's flavors, often compared favorably to pricier dairy-free options.

Build quality shines through ethical sourcing: Fairtrade-certified cocoa, sugar, and vanilla, plus non-GMO ingredients and responsibly sourced packaging. While not using dairy, it maintains Ben & Jerry's commitment to humane standards in production. The pint's compact dimensions ensure easy storage, fitting standard freezer shelves seamlessly.

Minor drawbacks include a potential weird aftertaste for some palates and the use of canola oil, which some avoid. Tolerance varies, but most find it negligible compared to the overall delight.

Verdict: A must-try for plant-based dessert seekers. This pint nails the dairy-free Milk & Cookies fantasy with superior creaminess and cookie overload, earning its high acclaim as a vegan staple.

Specifications

Product Dimensions: 3.88 x 3.88 x 4.11 inches; 1.05 Pounds

Item Model Number: 10076840002280

UPC: 076840002283

Manufacturer: Unilever

ASIN: B07Z8SCGP1

Units: 16.0 Ounce

Best Sellers Rank: #26,803 in Grocery & Gourmet Food; #6 in Plant-Based Ice Cream & Novelties

Ben & Jerry's Phish Food Ice Cream: Chocolate with Gooey Marshmallow, Caramel Swirls & Fudge Fish - 16oz Pint

Ben & Jerry's

View on Amazon Best Buy Walmart

Pros & Cons

Pros

Unique Phish band collaboration creates an iconic, involved flavor profile
Premium ethical sourcing with Fairtrade and humane standards
Exceptional texture from marshmallow, caramel, and fudge elements
Kosher certified and responsibly packaged for quality assurance

Cons

High sugar and calorie content typical of premium ice cream
Contains dairy and eggs, not suitable for vegans
Melts quickly in warm conditions like all ice creams

Ben & Jerry's Mint Chocolate Cookie Ice Cream Pint 16oz - Peppermint with Chocolate Cookies, Non-GMO, Fairtrade

Ben & Jerry's

View on Amazon Best Buy Walmart

Pros & Cons

Pros

Vibrant natural peppermint flavor rivals any mint ice cream
Generous cookie chunks provide satisfying texture
Ethically sourced with Fairtrade and non-GMO commitments
No artificial colors for pure, unsketchy enjoyment
Super premium quality from family-owned Ben & Jerry's

Cons

Not green-tinted, which may disappoint fans expecting traditional color
Dairy-based, unsuitable for vegans or lactose-intolerant eaters
Premium pricing reflects high-quality, sustainable ingredients

Ben & Jerry's Brand Guide

Brand Overview

Ben & Jerry's excels in the competitive grocery and gourmet food space, particularly with its non-dairy lineup that rivals traditional ice cream in creaminess and flavor depth. What sets them apart is the consistent high quality across products, evidenced by ratings like 4.6 stars for Non-Dairy Cherry Garcia and Non-Dairy Phish Food, and 4.5 stars for Non-Dairy "Milk" & Cookies. Customers praise the authentic taste profiles, from swirls of cherry and fudge to chocolatey caramel delights, all crafted with plant-based ingredients.

The brand's reputation rests on delivering value through superior texture and bold flavors in the frozen category, appealing to those who refuse to sacrifice enjoyment for dietary needs. Their focus on plant-based innovation positions them as a go-to for quality frozen desserts.

What to Expect from Ben & Jerry's Products

Ben & Jerry's non-dairy products share common strengths: exceptional creaminess from plant-based bases, generous mix-ins, and spot-on flavor replication that earns rave reviews. For instance, the Non-Dairy Cherry Garcia features whole cherries and fudge chunks in a cherry ice cream base, scoring 4.6 stars for its nostalgic appeal. Similarly, Non-Dairy Phish Food packs chocolate ice cream with gooey marshmallow, caramel swirls, and chocolatey fish-shaped pieces, also at 4.6 stars.

Texture: Smooth and scoopable, mimicking dairy ice cream without iciness.
Flavor Intensity: Bold and balanced, perfect for indulgent servings.
Portion Size: Convenient 16 oz pints ideal for sharing or savoring.

Priced as a premium option, these treats justify the investment with high satisfaction rates. They are best suited for vegans, lactose-intolerant individuals, and anyone craving dessert variety in the ice cream and novelties segment. Health-conscious shoppers appreciate the dairy-free formula while flavor purists love the uncompromised taste.

The Non-Dairy "Milk" & Cookies Vanilla Frozen Dessert, certified vegan at 4.5 stars, blends vanilla cookie swirls with chocolate sandwich cookies for a cookie dough-like experience. Overall, expect reliable quality that performs well straight from the freezer, making Ben & Jerry's a staple for plant-based frozen treats.

Shoppers often highlight the brand's ability to convert dairy ice cream lovers, with products holding strong in taste tests and repeat purchases. Whether exploring plant-based ice cream and novelties or seeking top-rated vegan options, Ben & Jerry's delivers consistency and delight.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, products like Non-Dairy Cherry Garcia, Phish Food, and "Milk" & Cookies are certified vegan, made with plant-based ingredients and no animal products. They cater specifically to dairy-free diets while maintaining high ratings of 4.5-4.6 stars. Always check labels for the latest certifications.

Top performers include Non-Dairy Cherry Garcia and Non-Dairy Phish Food, both at 4.6 stars, praised for their creamy texture and authentic flavors. The Non-Dairy "Milk" & Cookies earns 4.5 stars for its cookie-filled vanilla base. These stand out in customer reviews for taste.

Many reviewers note the plant-based versions closely mimic the dairy originals in creaminess and flavor, with hits like Cherry Garcia and Phish Food scoring identically high at 4.6 stars. The texture is smooth without graininess, making them indistinguishable for most fans.

Ben & Jerry's non-dairy pints are available in the frozen section of major grocery stores, online retailers, and specialty shops. Look in the plant-based ice cream and novelties category for 16 oz options like Phish Food and Cherry Garcia.

Absolutely, these products are dairy-free and suitable for lactose-intolerant individuals, using plant-based alternatives. High ratings (4.5-4.6 stars) confirm they provide indulgent satisfaction without digestive issues associated with dairy ice cream.