Menu

We independently review everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more ›

Best Cypress Grove Cheeses

Explore Cypress Grove Cheeses, featuring premium artisanal goat milk cheeses like Midnight Moon. Known for bold flavors and award-winning quality.

1 product

Select a Product

Click on a product from the list to view its details.

PRIME

ProductSearch.org score rating is a scoring system developed by our experts. The score is from 0 to 10 based on the data collected by the ProductSearch.org tool. This score doesn't impact from any manufacturer or sales agent websites. We encourage you to write a review of your experiences with these products. Learn more »
Last update on . Affiliate links, prices, images, product titles, and highlights from Amazon Product Advertising API.

Pros

Cons

Key Features

User Reviews

Your review will be visible after approval.

Loading reviews...
Cypress Grove Midnight Moon Gouda Cheese - Creamy Aged Goat Milk Delight, 16oz Wheel

Cypress Grove Midnight Moon is an aged Gouda-style cheese crafted from goat milk. Its ultra-creamy, slightly sweet flavor shines on cheese boards, ideal for gouda fans seeking luxurious everyday indulgence.

  • Indulge in ultra-creamy texture with a subtle crumble for pure cheese bliss
  • Enjoy slightly sweet, caramel-like notes without overpowering sharpness
  • Elevate cheese boards and pairings with wine or beer effortlessly
  • Savor premium goat milk quality that tastes purely like gourmet gouda
  • Relish as an everyday treat or introductory cheese for milder palates

Exceptional creamy sweetness and smooth mouthfeel. Versatile for boards, melting, or solo snacking. High-quality goat milk without any goaty aftertaste.

May lack expected tyrosine crystals in some wheels. Flavor leans mild, potentially too subtle for bold cheese lovers. Hint of olive noted by some, altering classic gouda profile.

Welcome to the premier destination for Cypress Grove Cheeses, where innovative cheesemaking meets unforgettable taste. This category showcases standout offerings like Midnight Moon, a beloved goat cheese that captures the essence of California's coastal farms. Whether you're a seasoned epicurean or a casual foodie, Cypress Grove delivers exceptional quality that elevates any meal or gathering.

The Legacy and Craftsmanship of Cypress Grove

Cypress Grove has built a stellar reputation since 1976 as a pioneer in American goat cheese production. Founded by Mary Keehn in Arcata, California, the brand revolutionized the U.S. cheese scene with fresh, flavorful goat milk cheeses made from milk sourced from local, humane farms. What sets Cypress Grove apart is their commitment to small-batch production, blending traditional European techniques with bold American innovation. Their cheeses consistently earn accolades at competitions like the American Cheese Society Awards, proving their standing among global gourmet favorites.

In this category, you'll find selections that highlight the brand's expertise in aged and flavored varieties. These cheeses stand out for their creamy textures, complex flavors, and versatility, making them ideal for those exploring beyond everyday dairy options.

Spotlight on Midnight Moon

Midnight Moon is the star of our Cypress Grove Cheeses collection—a semi-firm goat cheese aged for over six months. Inspired by Dutch gouda styles but crafted with goat milk, it boasts a golden hue, crunchy crystallization, and notes of caramel, nuts, and toffee. This cheese strikes a perfect balance between creamy richness and nutty depth, appealing to both novices and connoisseurs.

Buyers appreciate Midnight Moon for its approachable yet sophisticated profile. It's firm enough for slicing or cubing, yet melts beautifully in recipes. Consider factors like aging process when shopping: longer aging intensifies flavors and adds those signature crunchy bits, enhancing texture.

What to Look for in Cypress Grove Cheeses

When selecting from this category, prioritize these key features:

  • Flavor Profile: Cypress Grove excels in balanced tanginess from goat milk, often layered with sweet, nutty undertones.
  • Texture and Aging: From creamy fresh styles to firm, aged wheels like Midnight Moon, choose based on your pairing needs.
  • Sourcing and Sustainability: The brand emphasizes humane animal practices and eco-friendly farming, appealing to conscious consumers.
  • Versatility: Perfect for snacking, grating over salads, or incorporating into baked dishes.

Common use cases include charcuterie boards, where Midnight Moon pairs exquisitely with fruits, nuts, and wines; gourmet sandwiches for a tangy twist; or as a dessert cheese with honey drizzles. For everyday indulgence, slice it thin for crackers or melt into pasta sauces.

Pairing and Serving Tips

Elevate your experience with thoughtful pairings. Midnight Moon shines alongside crisp apples, pears, or dried figs for contrast. Bold red wines like cabernet sauvignon or ports complement its nuttiness, while IPAs cut through the richness. Serve at room temperature to unleash full aromas, and store wrapped in parchment in the fridge for optimal freshness.

If you're new to goat cheeses, start here before venturing into broader selections. For instance, compare with options in our Cheeses category or explore Packaged Cheese for convenient formats.

Comparing Cypress Grove to Other Brands

Cypress Grove's goat milk focus gives it an edge in creaminess and tang over cow's milk rivals. For those preferring Irish grass-fed varieties, check Kerrygold Cheeses, or discover everyday organics in 365 by Whole Foods Market Cheeses. Back in the larger Dairy, Eggs & Plant-Based Alternatives section, you'll find complementary items to build your cheeseboard.

Within Grocery & Gourmet Food, Cypress Grove fits seamlessly for premium upgrades.

FAQ

What makes Cypress Grove cheeses unique?

Cypress Grove specializes in goat milk cheeses with innovative flavors and textures, like the caramelized notes in Midnight Moon. Their artisanal process and sustainable sourcing set them apart from mass-produced options.

How should I store Midnight Moon?

Keep it wrapped in wax paper or parchment in the refrigerator's cheese drawer. Bring to room temperature before serving, and consume within weeks of opening for peak flavor.

Cypress Grove vs. other cheese brands?

Unlike cow's milk-heavy brands like Tillamook, Cypress Grove offers lighter, tangier goat cheeses ideal for digestive sensitivity. It's a gourmet choice over budget options.

Is Midnight Moon suitable for cooking?

Absolutely—its firm texture holds up in gratins, pizzas, or sauces, adding nutty depth without overpowering other ingredients.

Where does Cypress Grove source its milk?

From family-owned goat dairies in Northern California, ensuring fresh, high-quality milk with humane standards.