Menu

We independently review everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more ›

Best Rubbermaid Cutlery Trays

Rubbermaid cutlery trays offer durable, organized solutions for kitchen drawers. Featuring no-slip grips, adjustable dividers, and multiple compartments for effortless silverware storage.

3 products

Select a Product

Click on a product from the list to view its details.

PRIME

ProductSearch.org score rating is a scoring system developed by our experts. The score is from 0 to 10 based on the data collected by the ProductSearch.org tool. This score doesn't impact from any manufacturer or sales agent websites. We encourage you to write a review of your experiences with these products. Learn more »
Last update on . Affiliate links, prices, images, product titles, and highlights from Amazon Product Advertising API.

Pros

Cons

Key Features

User Reviews

Your review will be visible after approval.

Loading reviews...
Rubbermaid Adjustable Cutlery Tray White - Expandable Drawer Organizer 11.5-19" Wide, Non-Slip Grips, Dishwasher Safe

The Rubbermaid Adjustable Cutlery Tray in white expands from 11.5 to 19 inches to fit various kitchen drawers and stays securely in place with rubber grips on sides and bottom. Its standout roomy side compartments organize large gadgets alongside knives, spoons, and forks, making it perfect for busy home cooks seeking tidy drawers.

  • Expands effortlessly to fit drawers 11.5-19 inches wide for custom organization
  • Rubber grips on sides and bottom prevent sliding during drawer use
  • Roomy side compartments neatly store large utensils and gadgets
  • Dishwasher safe for quick, hassle-free cleaning
  • Keeps knives, spoons, and forks separated and accessible

Adjustable sizing fits most standard drawers. Superior non-slip stability enhances usability. Spacious for oversized tools without clutter.

Limited to drawers within 11.5-19 inch range. White color may show stains over time. Side compartments best for average-sized gadgets.

Rubbermaid No-Slip Silverware Organizer Tray, Large 7-Compartment Drawer Insert, Black/Grey Durable Plastic

This Rubbermaid No-Slip Silverware Tray is a large organizer with 7 compartments, including 5 slots and 2 expandable trays for flatware and utensils. Its standout no-slip base keeps it secure in drawers, making it perfect for busy households seeking durable, easy-to-clean storage.

  • Eliminates drawer clutter with 7 dedicated compartments for knives, forks, spoons, and serving utensils
  • No-slip base and feet ensure the tray stays put as drawers open and close, preventing spills
  • Expandable trays adapt to your flatware collection for customizable organization
  • Durable plastic construction offers a premium look and long-lasting strength
  • Dishwasher-safe design makes cleanup effortless after messy meals

Secure no-slip feature keeps everything in place during daily use. Ample storage with expandable sections for growing utensil needs. Sturdy, easy-to-clean material withstands heavy use.

Large size may not fit smaller or shallow drawers. Limited color options beyond black/grey. Compartments might feel snug for oversized serving utensils.

Rubbermaid Cutlery Tray Organizer - 5-Slot Silverware Drawer Tray for Knives, Forks, Spoons & Utensils - Made in USA

The Rubbermaid Cutlery Tray is a white plastic 5-slot organizer designed for knives, forks, spoons, and extra utensils in four-piece place settings. Its durable, Made in USA construction stands out for reliable kitchen drawer organization, ideal for homeowners seeking simple flatware storage.

  • Neatly separates knives, forks, and spoons to prevent clutter and tangling
  • Dedicated extra slot keeps gadgets and additional utensils accessible
  • Made in USA for superior durability and long-lasting performance
  • Fits standard four-piece place settings for everyday family use
  • Streamlines drawer organization to save time and reduce kitchen frustration

Multiple tailored compartments for efficient sorting. Ample space for utensils beyond basic flatware. High-quality American manufacturing ensures reliability.

Plastic construction may scratch over heavy use. Fixed dimensions might not suit oversized drawers. White color could show stains from frequent handling.

Keep your kitchen drawers tidy and functional with Rubbermaid cutlery trays, the go-to choice for homeowners seeking reliable organization. This category features three standout models: the classic Rubbermaid Cutlery Tray, the expansive No-Slip Silverware Tray Organizer with seven compartments, and the versatile Adjustable Cutlery Tray. These products excel in creating clutter-free spaces, making meal prep and cleanup a breeze while standing up to daily family use.

Why Rubbermaid Excels in Cutlery Trays

Rubbermaid has built a reputation for over 80 years as a leader in innovative home storage solutions, known for high-quality plastic construction that's both lightweight and incredibly tough. Their cutlery trays prioritize practicality with features like ribbed bottoms to prevent utensils from sliding and easy-to-clean surfaces that resist stains. Whether you're revamping a small apartment kitchen or outfitting a spacious family home, Rubbermaid trays fit standard drawers seamlessly, helping you maximize space in your Cabinet & Drawer Organization setup.

Key Features to Look For

When shopping for cutlery trays, focus on durability, compartment customization, and stability. Rubbermaid models shine here:

  • Material Quality: BPA-free, impact-resistant plastic ensures longevity without warping or cracking.
  • Non-Slip Design: Textured surfaces and grippy feet keep trays in place during drawer pulls.
  • Compartment Variety: From basic slots to seven dedicated sections for forks, spoons, knives, and gadgets.
  • Adjustability: Expandable dividers adapt to your utensil collection as it grows.
  • Size Options: Compact for shallow drawers or large for deep ones, fitting most cabinet dimensions.

These elements make Rubbermaid trays ideal for busy households, preventing the dreaded 'utensil avalanche' and saving time on daily searches.

Comparing Rubbermaid Cutlery Tray Models

Choosing the right model depends on your drawer size and storage needs. The standard Rubbermaid Cutlery Tray offers a straightforward, multi-compartment design perfect for everyday essentials—great for smaller kitchens where simplicity rules.

For larger collections, the No-Slip Silverware Tray Organizer in black with grey accents provides seven generous compartments and enhanced grip technology. Its durable plastic build handles heavy loads, making it a favorite for families with kids or frequent entertainers.

The Adjustable Cutlery Tray in white brings flexibility to the table, with movable dividers that let you customize sections on the fly. It's ideal if your utensil inventory changes seasonally or if you share drawers with roommates.

Side-by-side, the No-Slip model edges out for stability in high-traffic drawers, while the Adjustable version wins for versatility. All integrate smoothly into broader Storage & Organization systems, elevating your entire kitchen workflow.

Common Use Cases and Tips

Rubbermaid cutlery trays suit various scenarios: organizing post-move chaos, streamlining holiday prep, or maintaining order in rental kitchens. Install one in your silverware drawer to separate everyday flatware from specialty tools, or use multiples across drawers for gadgets and baking supplies.

Pro tip: Measure your drawer depth first—most Rubbermaid trays are low-profile for easy gliding. Pair with Racks & Holders for pots and pans to create a fully optimized Kitchen & Dining space. If Rubbermaid's ruggedness appeals but you want alternatives, explore madesmart® Cutlery Trays for slimmer profiles or JosephJoseph Cutlery Trays for modern aesthetics.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Rubbermaid cutlery trays dishwasher safe?

Yes, most models, including the No-Slip Organizer and Adjustable Tray, are top-rack dishwasher safe for effortless cleaning. Hand-washing the standard tray preserves its finish longer.

How do Rubbermaid trays compare to competitors?

Rubbermaid stands out for superior durability and no-slip features compared to brands like madesmart or JosephJoseph, offering better value for heavy-use kitchens without sacrificing style.

Which model should I choose?

Opt for the No-Slip Large if you have a big family; the Adjustable for customizable needs; or the classic for basic organization. Consider drawer size and utensil volume first.

What is Rubbermaid's warranty on these trays?

Rubbermaid typically offers a limited lifetime warranty against manufacturing defects, backed by responsive customer support for replacements or questions.

Can these trays fit in non-standard drawers?

The Adjustable model accommodates varying widths best, while others suit standard 18-21 inch drawers. Trim guides if needed, though they're designed for easy fit.